Two narratives I often hear thrown around about the Oscars and their waning importance/relevance: (1) they don’t reward the best movies, and (2) they don’t reward movies that the general public has seen en masse. Both points pass the validity smell test — take Green Book’s reputation and The Hurt Locker’s box office, for example — but I was curious what the data had to say about these claims so I went ahead and crunched some numbers.
To measure the public critical reception to the Oscars (we’ll look at the box office figures tomorrow), I isolated the films that won the “Big 8” categories — Best Picture, Best Director, the four acting awards, and the two screenplay awards — for each film year (not ceremony year) going back to 1957, the first year all eight categories existed in more or less their current form. For each winner, I charted their average score (transposed to a 100 point scale for ease of comparison) on the social film site Letterboxd, which I chose over other rating systems for several reasons: (a) Letterboxd has a robust film community which includes regular film lovers and professional critics, (b) the site has less of a review spamming reputation compared to audience ratings on the likes of IMDb or Rotten Tomatoes, and (c) they have a larger selection of available rating aggregations than a site like Metacritic, which simply didn’t feature several films from our dataset.
Once I had the Letterboxd rating for each winner, I averaged the eight ratings to obtain an average score for each film year at the Oscars (yes, this does mean that a film has more weight for winning multiple top awards).
Based on the results, we can perhaps extract a slight upward trend in how well the Oscar winners have been regarded over time, but for the most part things tend to fluctuate year-to-year — the films bottom out around an average rating of 65/100 (1963), peak just over 82/100 (1974 and 1976), and hang around in the 70s most of the time. All things considered, we could probably do a lot worse.
The full rankings are included in the table below for your perusal. Notice any trends? Drop us a line and let us know!
Kaiser OTC benefits provide members with discounts on over-the-counter medications, vitamins, and health essentials, promoting better health management and cost-effective wellness solutions.
Obituaries near me help you find recent death notices, providing information about funeral services, memorials, and tributes for loved ones in your area.
is traveluro legit? Many users have had mixed experiences with the platform, so it's important to read reviews and verify deals before booking.